Library

Colin's Essays
click here

Steve Hall's Essays
click here

*Past Delegates Refresher Room*
Power Point presentation for refreshing the memories of past delegates.
Click Here

 
You are here: Home / Colin's Leadership Blog / Matric results - Sinking deeper into mediocrity

Matric results - Sinking deeper into mediocrity

— filed under:

Address by Professor Jonathan Jansen, Vice-Chancellor of the University of the Free State

 

I have in front of me the 2010 "Statement of Results" for the National Senior Certificate statement of a youngster who demands to study at university. They are: Afrikaans 43, English 39, mathematical literacy 38, life orientation 78, business studies 41, computer applications technology 31, life sciences 28. At the bottom of the certificate is this unbelievable statement: "The candidate qualifies for the national senior certificate and fulfils the minimum requirements for admission to higher education."

Understandably, this young woman takes these words literally, and correctly demands a seat in any place of higher learning. With the young woman's claim to study I have no problem. With the society that sets the bar for performance so low, I have serious problems.
Slowly, slowly we are digging our collective graves as we fall into a sinkhole of mediocrity from which we are unlikely to emerge. We make excellence sound like a white thing. Behind a massive wave of populism, and in the misguided name of regstelling (setting right the past), we open access to resources and universities to young people without the hard work necessary to achieve those gifts and to succeed once there. Of course, you're a racist if you question this kind of mindlessness; how else do you, as a politician, defend yourself against the critics of mediocrity in an election year?

I miss Steve Biko. In the thinking of black consciousness, he would have railed against the low standards we set for black achievement, in the language of the 1970s. This young (incidentally black) person did not achieve anything above 50% in her Senior Certificate results for any exam subject, but we tell her she can proceed to higher studies. What are we saying? That black students are somehow less capable and therefore need these pathetic results to access higher education? No, I am sorry, but today I am angry about the messages we send our children.

I saw black parents and students squirm the other night when I addressed a racially diverse group of parents and students and made this point clear: "If a black student requires from you different treatment and lower academic demands because of an argument about disadvantage, tell them to take a hike." (Okay, I used stronger language.)

I saw white teachers squirm when I made the other important point: "If you have lower academic expectations of black children because of what they look like, or where they come from, that is the worst kind of racism." Our society, schools and universities have adjusted expectations downwards, especially in relation to black students, and that is dangerous in a country with so much promise for excellence.

As stories come rolling in from across the country for our Great South African Teachers book, I am struck by one thing. That many black professionals who are chartered accountants, medical scientists or corporate lawyers tell of attending ordinary public schools under apartheid, often in rural areas, and having teachers at the time who, despite the desperate poverty and inequality, held high expectations of their learners. There was no compromising on academic standards; there was homework every day; there was punishment for low performance; and there was constant motivation to rise above your circumstances.

Not today. Mathematical literacy is a cop-out, a way of compensating for poor maths teaching in the mainstream. Parents of Grade 9 children, listen carefully - do not let your school force your child into mathematical literacy because they will struggle to find access to academic degree studies at serious universities. Insist your child does mathematics in Grade 10 for that important choice determines what your child writes in Grade 12.

It is not, of course, mathematical literacy that I am concerned about; there are good teachers of the subject. It is about the message we send: that children can't do maths. In other words, a message again communicated of low expectations. Do not buy into this culture of mediocrity in the way your child makes subject choices. Also, tell your child not to take life orientation seriously; as you can see in the above results, there is no positive relationship between high marks in academic subjects and this thing called life orientation.

Small wonder young people with better results than those above are without work. The marketplace, and serious universities, know this child will not succeed with these kinds of results, even if Umalusi does not "get it".

Read latest article published in Moneyweb by Professor Jansen, click here

Document Actions

Matric Results Sinking!

Avatar Posted by Ntuthu Peter at Aug 24, 2011 12:19 PM
What Prof Jonathan is saying its so true. I fully agree with his views. Our black Community really have a problem with perfoming academically. However I believe that something can be done with predicament, we youth need to be thought how to take full responsibility of their lives and future.

It can also be argued that they do not get support from the families. Forinstance in the White communities, parents are very much involved in their children education, their children are exposed to so much information at the very young age, and they are also taught how to work hard.

We can blame them yes, but are we giving them support, do we take time to find out what exactly they love, and what they will want to become, and lead them accordingly.

It really hurts me to see black youth performing so badly, because they are our future leaders.

Lets please support and educate them.

Miss Peter

Death of a young mind

Avatar Posted by Stephanie at Jan 10, 2012 02:40 PM
"I saw white teachers squirm when I made the other important point: "If you have lower academic expectations of black children because of what they look like, or where they come from, that is the worst kind of racism." "

You realise that the black teachers do exactly the same, and on the other hand white children are also starting to play the disadvantaged card. The other issue is that the youth of today have this wonderful thing called "entitlement". They strongly believe that the world will just fall into their laps... I mean why would they think any differently when we have Presidents and Ministers who barely have better marks than they do. My son is 12 and he came home with this horrible joke, the basic idea was: "If you want to be President/Minister in SA get a criminal record, get into the business of fraud and say things like you will take a shower to get rid of AIDS!"
I was horrified! But this is the message our children are getting! I can assure you that my son with think six times before he retells that "joke".
Children learn by example, and we as parents, teachers and elders are not setting a very good one.
  

Fantastic

Avatar Posted by Chris at Jan 10, 2012 02:42 PM
This man is a genius and not scared to speak the truth.

Dumbed down education = dumbed down people = dumbed down population = a economic massacre by the other developing nations who do not tolerate this crap! Wake up South Africa or we truly will become second rate!

Matric results sinking

Avatar Posted by Kpax at Jan 10, 2012 02:44 PM
Prof Jonathan is so right.

I went to school in the Eastern Cape in a not so affluent school. I suffered but managed to get the necessary results to make it to university. My first year of university was a shock for me but I managed to stay in university until I finished my degree. At the end of my first year I witnessed a lot of my classmates get excluded from the university due to the poor academic results they obtained (most of them were of colour).

I then start thinking; who is the government trying to help by lowering the standards of education. Definitely not the students who get excluded after the first year who end up with debt from the loan they took out to pay their fees.

I must admit though that there are some pupils who were previously disadvantaged but they should have the results to prove that they have a chance of surviving in a higher education environment. This candidates whose results are displayed above should not be given false hope of their survival at any university.

Thank you for your article; it needed to be said!


Matric becoming so easy now

Avatar Posted by Paul de Stadler at Jan 10, 2012 02:46 PM
When i look back at my matric in 1985, we got no grace for bad performance, we had to make sure we worked and studied and got through.The matric today is not going to count much as it is obvious that 70.20% passed which does not sound right at all. I did all my subjects in Higher Grade. I worked dam hard to achieve my matric pass.South Africa is going back in education and i want to see what the Government is going to do when majority of the students drop out of higher education center's as you are not spoon fed, but have to use your skills at school and apply them in higher education. This Government has made a total mess of the education system. 95% of students enrolling at University today are going to drop out in the first year and how can you engineering for example with maths literacy and not higher grade mathematics ad science... I agree with the article 1000%

response to article

Avatar Posted by Kamo at Jan 10, 2012 02:48 PM
Ms Peter is right, the parents getting in involved goes a long way in shaping how the child will perform academically. My father always made us take two hours out of after school play time to go over what we learnt in class that day, whether it was homework or not. He attended parent evenings, sports days and other extra mural activities which ensured that we did well because someone was interested in our educational development from the home front. Parents need to start caring.

Poor Matric results

Avatar Posted by Thabang Lenoge at Jan 10, 2012 02:50 PM
South Africa was not build on individualism but rather on a collection of high ideals and the pursuit of freedom and equality for all South Africans! I am of the opinion that both universities and government are responsible for coming up with a collective system of ideas which may influence the quality of teaching in South Africa. We have moved away from the basic fundamentals of learning not forgetting that we also come from a history of denial and of being disenfranchised! What is being taught on television is absolute rubbish! Parents need help in order to interpret this new curriculum that even the teachers don't understand! Why is the standard of teaching In Zimbabwe and Nigeria better than in South Africa, the leader of the continent! I hold the government largely responsible for the mess education is in because it has failed to build a university in the Northern Cape where we were the producing the best learners from the year 2000!

Is This Racism!?

Avatar Posted by Jock at Jan 10, 2012 02:53 PM
My children are in a private school, the school had a 100% pass rate for 2011 and they follow the British curriculum which standards are much higher than the public schools in South Africa.

I'm paying a fortune every month for school fees, I have no choice, I want to see my children grow to the best of their abilities and succeed in life, I don't want to put them in public schools which are filled with racial tension, drugs and they might even get stabbed with a knife at school.

I think everything is interlinked: Why do we have so much corruption, incompetency, rapes, violent crime etc. etc.
This has to do with the morality of a nation, if your leaders are corrupt and have bad standards why should their followers be any different.

Go look at Japan, to mention just 1 nation, they are the most respectful, humble, dedicated and hard-working people I've seen, they have the utmost respect for life - when looking at the characteristically and crime stats in SA it appears we are just the opposite of the Japanese.

And NO, millions of Japanese children/students don't have "rich white" parents to motivate and pay for them, their own standards are just naturally high.

Time to raise the bar, time to say enough is enough and kick out any government official etc. who does not meet this standard, the same standards will also mean zero tolerance on savage rapists, murderers...lets clean up this country and measure ourselves against the best in the world, not the scum of the world.

South Africa - Sinking deeper into mediocrity

Avatar Posted by WM at Jan 11, 2012 03:27 PM
It sickens me when every single time there is a problem, the race card has to be taken out. Always the black person being the oppressed victim, always the white person being the racist. Look at every single successful person, black or white, and you will see that they worked hard at their education. They had vision and purpose. They believed in themselves and set their own standards high.

The evil apartheid government built 10 universities for blacks including Medunsa that tought and trained 200 highly qualified black doctors every year. Nelson Mandela even got his Law degree at the University of Witwatersrand, even Jonathan Jansen as a black person that grew up in Apartheid flourished and made something of himself. You get pathetic grades in the black community as well as in the white community just as you get high level achievers in both communities. It's not a question about race, it's a question of what you think of yourself.

It is the ANC who allowed the drop in standards... It is the ANC who changed our school system to the USA system, and if Jonathan Jansen just done the effort of looking beyond the entire racism bullshit he would realize that all the schools in the USA has also dropped significantly in standards (specifically aimed at the white kids). It's not only in South Africa, it's not about creating brilliant minds, it's about stupefying and dumbing down the next generation.

You cannot address one problem without understanding all the other problems surrounding it. We were too busy with worrying about AIDS medication, RDP housing programs, unemployment, new gun laws, new legislation, fighting for money to feed our families and we didn't even realise what happened under our noses. Today not much have changed.

Prof Jonathan might be brilliant, but this article clearly does not display that.

School system - sinking deeper into mediocrity

Avatar Posted by Mike at Jan 11, 2012 03:42 PM
Horror! upon horrors!
While listening to KFM radio this morning the GK Teens program came on. The two participants were grade 12 pupils from two of our "previously" top girl's schools. The first question asked was "how much is 9 x 8" the question was passed. Later the participant was asked whar Dermatitus is. She passed on that question apart from other as well. The next participant had similar results, also not being able to answer the simple times table question.
What are the children of today being taught?? In my school days a standard 5 pupil would have been able to answer those questions. I can only agree with WM - "it's not about creating brilliant minds, it's about stupefying and dumbing down the next generation."
Educators hang your heads in shame!!


Schooling results

Avatar Posted by Hermanean at Jan 12, 2012 11:19 AM
I just seem to have another take on all of this!! Being an educational psychologist and having been employed by an education department for many years I realise that all the previous comments are to a greater or lesser degree correct. The probelm is some, if not all of it. Collectively we are all on board this mother ship called "south africa"! We are not passengers we are all crew. The overriding issue is that so much is made of the matric results anmd not enough to ensure that learners that are not meeting their academic standards are examined in each of their contexts. Some learners have psyhco social or psycho edcutaional factors limiting them to perform. My perception is that this is but a contributary cause, the greatest factor, I believe is the attitude of teachers and their total lack of committment to teaching not only in the high school level but throughout the system. hardly have I come across a case where a teacher has actually taken the trouble to find out why their particular learner is not performing and does something about it. Either the blame is put on the previous classroom teachers or the blame is on the system- never on the self. Mediocrity is a sign of teacher's attitudes to learning. it reflects their total non- committment to education. Teaching is hard work, teaahing is dedication teaching is passion. Teaching is the love of children and or students. Its is the realisation that each learner in your hands is worthy. If you can't or don't want to teach... get out!!! Those of you that have been taught by Jonathan Jansen would know what I am talking about. Schooling as a life long process it matters!! Their are education departments that are putting in millions upon millions into the non- performing schools. Some, like I, would see this as rewarding mediocrity. Departments would do better just to fire the principals and teachers.

Add comment

You can add a comment by filling out the form below. Plain text formatting.

(Required)
Tell us your name.
(Required)
Enter your e-mail address.
(Required)
(Required)
(Required)
Enter the word